“The Sin Eater” knocks it out of the park, pun intended. After a three week hiatus, Sleepy Hollow comes to bat ready to hit home runs for the rest of the season. “The Sin Eater” makes no apologies as it roars through in a most frightening manner with talk of demons and sin. Nightmare sequences complete with crackling lightning, a crying baby, strange looking dolls, and a headless horseman – all things that would make anyone cringe.